← All episodes
S2E03

From Molecules to Markets: Venture Scaling the Energy Transition with Rudolf Zauner|@verbundag|S2E3

with Rudolf Zauner· Verbund AG· 64m

TL;DR

Verbund's Rudolf Zauner discusses pioneering green hydrogen, scaling renewables, and investing in energy transition startups via Verbund Ventures.

Synopsis
Rudolf Zauner, a veteran of the energy industry and Verbund AG, shares his journey from building a small hydropower plant in the 80s to leading innovation at Austria's largest utility. He details Verbund's early ventures into renewables in Eastern Europe and Spain, highlighting the challenges of developing projects in nascent markets and the importance of local partnerships and community integration. Zauner also recounts Verbund's pioneering role in green hydrogen, including the H2Future project, which deployed a 6 MW PEM electrolyzer at voestalpine in 2019. The discussion shifts to Verbund Ventures, the utility's investment arm, which focuses on late seed and Series A funding for clean tech startups across Europe. Zauner emphasizes the critical role of innovation, strategic investments, and robust policy frameworks in accelerating the energy transition. He also touches upon the challenges of achieving 100% renewable electricity, the need for interdisciplinary skills, and the importance of customer-centric approaches in technology adoption.

Key metrics

by the numbers · 8
  • 8 kW
    Pelton turbine capacity
  • 98%
    Verbund renewable generation share
  • 35 TWh
    Verbund annual generation
  • 6 MW
    H2Future electrolyzer capacity
  • 27 TWh
    Austrian 2030 renewable electricity gap
  • €2.5 million
    Verbund Ventures maximum investment
  • 10
    Verbund Ventures startup investments
  • €6 billion
    Verbund green infrastructure investment

Topics

8 tags
HydropowerGreen HydrogenVenture CapitalEnergy StorageGrid FlexibilityPolicy RiskElectrificationTalent Shortage
Stats
Duration
1h 03m
Words
10.2k
Questions
102

Timeline

10 chapters
  1. Built Small Hydropower Plant

    Rudolf Zauner and schoolmates designed and constructed an 8 kW Pelton turbine hydropower plant in the Alps, which is still operational.

  2. Joined Verbund, Renewable Power Founded

    Rudolf Zauner joined Verbund when Verbund Renewable Power was founded, starting his career in renewable project development.

  3. Verbund's First Greenfield Wind Projects

    Verbund developed its first greenfield wind projects in Romania's Dobrogea region, building infrastructure from scratch and integrating with local communities.

  4. First PV Projects in Spain

    Verbund initiated its first photovoltaic projects in Spain, navigating a nascent market with many unverified development proposals.

  5. Verbund Initiated Green Hydrogen Program

    Verbund began its innovation program for green hydrogen, aiming to extend its value chain from electricity to green molecules.

  6. H2Future Project Granted EU Funding

    The H2Future project, a large-scale green hydrogen initiative, received EU funding, becoming a lighthouse project for industrial electrolyzer deployment.

  7. 6 MW PEM Electrolyzer Operational

    A 6 MW PEM electrolyzer, the world's largest at the time, went into operation at voestalpine's steelworks in Linz as part of the H2Future project.

  8. Green Hydrogen at Blue Danube Project Idea

    Rudolf Zauner conceived the 'green hydrogen at Blue Danube' project to produce green hydrogen in Romania/Bulgaria and transport it via the Danube to off-takers in Austria/Germany.

  9. Christian Doppler Laboratory Started

    Verbund started a Christian Doppler laboratory with the Technical University of Vienna to scale up oxygen ion battery technology, aiming for a spin-off.

  10. Verbund Ventures Launched

    Verbund launched Verbund Ventures, its investment vehicle, to invest in late seed and Series A clean tech startups across Europe.

Key insights

5 takeaways
  • 01

    Policy Stability Crucial for Investment

    Unpredictable policy changes, such as solar taxes or certificate cuts, severely erode investor confidence and hinder renewable energy deployment in emerging markets.

  • 02

    Last 10% Renewables Very Expensive

    Achieving 100% renewable electricity, especially the final 5-10%, becomes disproportionately expensive due to the need for seasonal storage and other costly solutions. Reallocating funds to other decarbonization efforts might yield greater CO2 reduction.

  • 03

    Europe's Innovation-to-Market Gap

    Europe excels in basic research but struggles to industrialize innovations, creating a 'value of death' for startups. A shift in funding towards pilots and first-of-a-kind projects is needed to bridge this gap.

  • 04

    Hydrogen Cost Reduction Challenges

    Electrolyzer costs may decrease with scale, but the balance of plant, which constitutes a large portion of a hydrogen facility, uses mature technologies with limited further cost reduction potential, making overall cost reduction difficult.

  • 05

    Interdisciplinary Skills Drive Innovation

    The energy transition requires professionals with interdisciplinary knowledge and a curious mindset to identify niches and foster innovation, particularly at the interfaces of different technologies and disciplines.

Pull quotes

5 quotes
  • Veteran is one word. Vintage is another word.
  • Verbund is the largest Austrian electricity utility. We're very proud of our very clean generation spread around 98% of our energy production of electricity production comes from renewables.
  • He laid out he well, said that Europe is very good in basic research, but we are not bringing research into products and into industrialization.
  • What you can electrify, you will electrify, yeah?
  • Try to be interdisciplinary, yeah? Because I think especially if you are curious and you have to be curious, I think, there you find the niches and the really interesting stuff, yeah?
Transcript1670 cuesClick a timestamp to jump
  1. Welcome to a new interview here in the
  2. energy bridge. Today we are in Fair Wind
  3. facilities
  4. in investment hope. Amazing.
  5. so today we have the pleasure to have
  6. Rudolf Zauner.
  7. It's the person behind the Fair Wind
  8. innovation for new
  9. Man of the Man of the person.
  10. Yeah, so very happy thank you for
  11. having us here and happy to have a
  12. conversation with you today and know
  13. more about Fair Wind X. Yeah, exactly.
  14. Thank you very much Rudolf first of all
  15. for giving us the time. And you
  16. Yeah, we can safely say you're the
  17. veteran. You have seen
  18. You have seen the energy transition.
  19. Now this jokes aside, thank you very
  20. much for joining us.
  21. Yeah, please tell us
  22. how how did it all start? Like how you
  23. tell us a bit about your journey and how
  24. you got into the energy industry.
  25. Walk us through.
  26. Sure, thank you very much for having
  27. me here.
  28. Veteran is one word. Vintage is another
  29. word.
  30. So
  31. whatever you want to call it but I've
  32. been around for quite some time in the
  33. energy business so that's that's the
  34. that's a definite here. As mentioned, my
  35. name is Rudi Rudi Zauner and I have been
  36. working for Fair Wind for quite some
  37. time for 20 years. Wow. But my my
  38. journey into renewables actually began
  39. far earlier.
  40. I did
  41. technical school for mechanical
  42. engineering a HTL we call it in Austria.
  43. And as one of the projects there
  44. actually it was a private project we
  45. built a small hydropower plant.
  46. At school, yeah. So it was actually my
  47. seatmate who had the idea. He went on a
  48. hiking trip to the Alps and went to this
  49. chalet and they didn't have any
  50. electricity. So, how can we help them?
  51. We can build a small hydropower plant.
  52. It took us a couple of years,
  53. from developing, designing. We did all
  54. the construction ourselves, even the
  55. casting of the
  56. of the turbine blades, everything
  57. ourselves together with
  58. schoolmates, of course. And we're very
  59. proud in late '80s we could then
  60. actually
  61. opening it. The opening ceremony was
  62. also quite a quite a thing. The local
  63. politicians came and it was even in
  64. the Austrian Verbund magazine at that
  65. time, some 40-odd years ago. And it was
  66. really good and it's still up and
  67. running. It's an 8 kW Pelton turbine
  68. that we built there. So, this was
  69. actually I think this was my first
  70. hands-on renewables project. I was
  71. always interested in that. Yeah, an
  72. entrepreneur like from Vinnity Nayer.
  73. Well, yeah.
  74. Yeah, well, you have to try things out,
  75. otherwise you don't know whether they
  76. work or not. Yeah. Totally. From that on
  77. well, I was very fascinated with
  78. chemical engineering
  79. and of unit operations because you
  80. can put them together like jigsaw
  81. puzzles. and jigsaw pieces and you
  82. can create your own processes,
  83. sustainable processes, environmentally
  84. friendly processes out of that.. So,
  85. I decided to
  86. get chemical engineering in Graz and
  87. I specialized in environmental
  88. engineering there.
  89. And did my PhD then in at UCL in
  90. London in process technology. So, this
  91. was actually my my way, but it was
  92. always a little bit, let's say, I was
  93. always very much looking into renewables
  94. and into environmental friendly
  95. technologies, yeah.
  96. So, yeah, I think there has been an
  97. early interest in sustainability and in
  98. environmentally friendly processes. And
  99. yeah, with Verbund I found my
  100. fulfillment because it's a purely
  101. renewable company, almost purely
  102. renewable company. So, I'm very happy to
  103. be here. And you started your career
  104. here.
  105. Oh, no, I actually didn't. No. I Well, I
  106. went abroad for quite some time. I was
  107. abroad for about 10 years, yeah.
  108. >> Yeah. Well, as I said, I did my PhD
  109. in London at UCL and started my
  110. career in Germany at BASF, big chemical
  111. company. Very nice playground for young
  112. young engineers, everything
  113. there. Huge operations, many, many
  114. processes, many plants next to each
  115. other. It was just huge and a very good
  116. learning ground..
  117. started there and then
  118. I was thinking about coming back to
  119. Austria, but then there was this job
  120. opening by Austrian Research Centers.
  121. They had actually opened a branch in the
  122. States in Pennsylvania for technology
  123. transfer. So, I said, well, before
  124. coming back to Austria, let's take the
  125. US as well.
  126. So, I spent a couple of years in the in
  127. the US and yeah, it was very exciting
  128. times.
  129. where I worked on technology
  130. transfer, then came back to Austrian
  131. Research Centers where I worked on a new
  132. technology called powder injection
  133. molding where we started development
  134. center, helped the Austrian industry.
  135. and then well,
  136. there comes this time in your life that
  137. you think, well,
  138. what is it really about and what do I
  139. want to do, yeah? And then I saw
  140. just by chance this job opening in
  141. one of the newspapers. By that time you
  142. looked at newspapers, not in the
  143. internet or anyway anywhere else. And
  144. saw that Verbund was looking for an
  145. expert in renewable energies. And I
  146. thought, well, I'm not an expert, but
  147. I'll just try to apply, yeah. I applied
  148. and this was actually when Verbund
  149. Renewable Power was founded and by that
  150. time I joined Verbund. Yeah, some 20
  151. years ago.
  152. you, Rudolf. Tell us a bit about
  153. Verbund as well in the legacy of
  154. Verbund. Yeah, Verbund is the largest
  155. Austrian electricity utility. We're very
  156. proud of our very clean generation
  157. spread around 98% of our energy
  158. production of electricity production
  159. comes from renewables. Mostly, of
  160. course, from our legacy technology
  161. hydropower.. But we have added quite
  162. a bit of wind and solar to our portfolio
  163. as well. And this is also something
  164. why I came into the company. I worked in
  165. the renewables field. My first projects
  166. were renewable projects in Spain,
  167. PV projects, and of course, also some
  168. projects in Eastern Europe. And I think
  169. this makes a probably a nice bridge to
  170. your bridge.
  171. Yeah. And you were, just first of
  172. all,
  173. how big is the portfolio of Verbund in
  174. megawatts?
  175. Our Well, I can I can tell you the
  176. annual generation that we have. That's
  177. around, I think, 35
  178. terawatt hours. And if you compare it to
  179. the Austrian electricity demand, which
  180. lies around between
  181. 65 to 70. So, it's it's a quite a quite
  182. a quite a bit. Yeah. And as I mentioned,
  183. mostly hydropower. We also have pumped
  184. storage. Whenever you're in the Alps and
  185. and walk around, go on a hiking trip,
  186. you see some reservoirs. So, most of
  187. them belong to us as well. So, they are
  188. help very much as our green alpine
  189. batteries to shift the energy between
  190. Yeah, to the grid.
  191. Exactly. Exactly. And we need more of
  192. it. With more renewables, we will need
  193. far more flexibility. And do you
  194. have more projects in Eastern Europe?
  195. Yeah, we have
  196. we have projects
  197. in development and actually in operation
  198. in Romania.
  199. we have projects in Albania as well,
  200. yeah.
  201. yeah, I think these are our two current
  202. Eastern Europe production units. I hope
  203. I haven't forgotten any any anything,
  204. but I think I'm very sure about those.
  205. And in terms of all the geographical
  206. footprint around around Austria, which
  207. other countries Verbund is active? We
  208. are very active in Germany and very
  209. active in Spain as well, where we also
  210. build a portfolio of solar
  211. mostly and wind. of course. yeah,
  212. we have footprint in Germany. One of my
  213. first wind projects were actually in
  214. Germany in the Hunsrück. yeah, we
  215. have of course projects in Austria also,
  216. not only in hydropower, but also in wind
  217. and PV and various technologies.
  218. Yeah, in Albania, we have hydropower. We
  219. are planning here wind projects as well.
  220. And in Romania was also first greenfield
  221. wind projects that we had some 15 years
  222. ago.
  223. and Verbund Renewable Power, they
  224. there was actually long time our largest
  225. wind portfolio with a couple of hundred
  226. megawatts. It's in the eastern part of
  227. Romania in the Dobrogea region, where we
  228. really started from scratch.
  229. >> And 15 years ago,
  230. how was it back in the time to
  231. develop something? Yeah, it
  232. It was It was It was quite different,
  233. yeah. It because
  234. wind and solar were quite edgy
  235. technologies. They were not mainstream
  236. or anything at all, yeah. And
  237. it was a time of, going
  238. somewhere and not knowing what to
  239. expect, yeah. So, one thing that we
  240. quickly found out was
  241. in countries like Romania, so it's very
  242. good to work with local partners. So,
  243. for the development of our projects, we
  244. partnered up with a local partner
  245. because I said we started from scratch.
  246. It was wasn't even a substation there,
  247. so we built a substation that feeds
  248. into the 400 kV grid of
  249. Transelectrica, the
  250. Romanian TSO, also. That has to be
  251. there had to be there as well. It now
  252. also other wind park
  253. operators feed into that. So, we were
  254. really the first ones there, well, first
  255. or second or so.
  256. and we had to
  257. yeah, get all the infrastructure done
  258. and everything, yeah. So, we worked a
  259. lot with local people, which is
  260. also very important to also integrate
  261. the local community., we had to
  262. build the infrastructure, the streets,
  263. and everything. And later on, when we
  264. were there, we also we sponsored the
  265. kindergarten, the local kindergarten,
  266. and so on, really got involved in the in
  267. the community. So, it's very very
  268. important. We hired local staff, of
  269. course. It was really
  270. good to see how people liked to work in
  271. the wind farms, yeah. They really saw
  272. this as a chance, yeah. They worked very
  273. hard, had very good work ethics, and it
  274. was really it was a great time, yeah,
  275. a great time of something something is
  276. changing..
  277. Exciting.
  278. And
  279. so, that would be the learning from
  280. Romania to integrate also the community.
  281. and you had similar projects
  282. what other projects 15 years ago, let's
  283. start
  284. that you started and it felt like a
  285. really massive things and now it feels
  286. way more way more easier, let's One of
  287. our first projects was in Spain..
  288. on photovoltaics, yeah. So, it was a
  289. time when many developers were actually
  290. developing projects, but not that many
  291. pulled actually through, yeah. So, this
  292. is something
  293. that was special to this time as well.
  294. There were many many projects out there,
  295. and you did didn't really know which one
  296. will actually make it to the final
  297. investment decision, yeah, because there
  298. was such a lot out there. And did they
  299. really have permit, and were they
  300. water tight or not?
  301. were there any land restrictions or
  302. anything. Yeah, so it was really it was
  303. a bit of a messy ground where we where
  304. we had to move around, yeah. And but I
  305. think this has changed now.
  306. there's regulation in place, there's
  307. policy in place, there's far far more,
  308. let's say, legal backing how to tackle
  309. such projects. But at the very beginning
  310. this was very in the flow. Let's call it
  311. in the flow, yeah. I can imagine that
  312. the amount of due diligences
  313. doing back in the time. If you have a
  314. huge pool and you don't know which one.
  315. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, you so you had
  316. to visit it sites, the individual sites,
  317. check the data, the winds data of the
  318. of the years before and so on. We
  319. worked with some very specialized
  320. consultants at that time. They were also
  321. some kind of pioneers in this time and
  322. it was it was kind of
  323. an area of an era of pioneers, I would
  324. call it. So that is really was really
  325. great to be part of that. Yeah,
  326. that's in 2010 kind of around between
  327. Yeah, yeah.
  328. A bit before that actually. Yeah, yeah.
  329. And regarding that we are in
  330. interested in Eastern region
  331. and you are you have presence there.
  332. In your vision, what is your
  333. opinion with the biggest challenge that
  334. this region is facing because they are
  335. relying more in fossil fuels?
  336. And having said that Central and Eastern
  337. Europe. Yeah, Central and Eastern
  338. Europe. Yeah,
  339. there's still a long way to go in the
  340. energy transition. Yeah, some coal-fired
  341. power plants that have to be
  342. closed down.
  343. Probably
  344. the financial costs are higher in those
  345. countries because the country risks are
  346. higher. So it's more difficult to get
  347. projects financed. And I think this is
  348. something
  349. projects in this
  350. region of CEE are still still facing,
  351. yeah. I think now the infrastructure
  352. has really caught up quite a bit, yeah.
  353. the infrastructure in terms of, let's
  354. say, roads and accessibility to the
  355. sites, the infrastructure of
  356. telecommunications, and so I think this
  357. is now really a good standard, yeah, so
  358. that you can build on, yeah. And this
  359. definitely has changed since then. This
  360. telling of the risk is something that we
  361. are addressing with the forums that we
  362. are organizing to de-risk the region
  363. through
  364. more information, more transparency,
  365. like putting people together, policy
  366. makers, industry. So, yeah, we also
  367. identified
  368. this risk. That's definitely a very
  369. important job that you are doing,
  370. and you are doing it How do you do that,
  371. actually? To bring those stakeholders
  372. together? basically, we are
  373. taking the bridge concept from the EU
  374. Commission of getting gathering the
  375. regional stakeholders together. So, the
  376. reason that we have chosen in Central
  377. and Eastern Europe. And before you were
  378. asking us why we chose this region,
  379. so it's actually because
  380. this this region has like similar
  381. journey in energy transition.
  382. and they the consolidation of
  383. ecosystem still needs to happen. And
  384. because of last couple of years of how
  385. things have happened, they really need
  386. to leapfrog their energy transition
  387. journey.. And they had to have
  388. certain players like ourselves and many
  389. others who who are able to solve the
  390. coordination gap between different
  391. stakeholders of academia, industry,
  392. policy makers, and strategic financing
  393. for the projects. So, yeah, we
  394. are addressing that through our
  395. forums, where we take particular
  396. topics, and Austria has to be the
  397. regional model within Central and
  398. Eastern Europe, so we do our forums in
  399. Vienna.
  400. And for any particular topic, we
  401. make sure that all the stakeholders are
  402. present so that any discussion could be
  403. outcome-oriented. So, that's how we are
  404. addressing via forum. We do other
  405. things as well, but that's about the
  406. forum. Yeah, so it's like a good plan,
  407. yeah. Yeah, so in it's
  408. inviting policy makers into the
  409. discussion as well because energy is
  410. super regulated sector.
  411. And
  412. main risk because I'm a developer by
  413. myself, so
  414. it's the legal certainty.
  415. So, helping policy makers to go through
  416. or to set a certain
  417. even
  418. the rules can can be super different,
  419. but having rules enable more investment.
  420. Yeah, and sticking to the rules is very
  421. for an investor that they don't change
  422. later on. Yeah, during
  423. This has done a lot of damage in some of
  424. the markets. Yeah. Yeah, I was in
  425. Spain in the
  426. Yeah, with the solar tax that they had.
  427. And also I think in Romania they
  428. introduced
  429. some some cuts of the certificates and
  430. so there there various things that
  431. that happened that really do not
  432. build the confidence of investors,
  433. yeah. Also, we felt that the whole
  434. innovation gap between how the
  435. technology is moving and how the
  436. regulation is moving is something to be
  437. addressed if we really want the
  438. deployment to happen faster. Now,
  439. speaking about energy transition and
  440. some like a bit of dreaming, what would
  441. you do
  442. if you had 1 billion euros? Where
  443. Where would you bet? More in
  444. long-term storage or more maybe
  445. flexibility or demand response or
  446. permitting reforms, maybe? But I think
  447. renewable build-out is a kind of a
  448. no-brainer, yeah? But it has to be
  449. orchestrated, I think, yeah? With the
  450. right renewables in the right place at
  451. the right time. It has to be coordinated
  452. with flexibility build out and with grid
  453. build out. Flexibility build out, I
  454. mean,
  455. storage and demand flexibility for
  456. time-wise shifting and grid flexibility
  457. for geographical shifting. Because only
  458. then renewables will come to their full
  459. potential, yeah? So, I would
  460. I would spend some money
  461. on
  462. on those
  463. Well, I would not spend it. I would
  464. invest it. I would invest it, yeah?
  465. In those technologies.
  466. But
  467. all of the technologies you mentioned,
  468. we will somehow need them all because it
  469. will be a mix at the end of the day,
  470. yeah? And we will need
  471. reliable and rigid policies as well,
  472. yeah? We'll probably need some
  473. incentives at the beginning to get
  474. things off the ground, yeah? So, it will
  475. be a mixture, I think, yeah?
  476. So, I would not bet it on one thing,
  477. but invest it more broadly. Talking
  478. about different technology, you have
  479. been one of the way early mover in green
  480. hydrogen.
  481. Tell us about the
  482. early projects that you got into it and
  483. before that whole hydrogen high powered,
  484. why you started working on
  485. it and what were the project about?
  486. About 10 years ago, Verbund started to
  487. move into into green hydrogen and yeah,
  488. being a chemical engineer, I put my hand
  489. up and said, "Well, here I am."
  490. And said, "Well, this is a topic I
  491. believe in and that could really
  492. become great and we have to have a
  493. closer look at it.
  494. We looked at the role that Verbund
  495. could play. We wanted to extend our
  496. value chain from an electricity producer
  497. to a provider of green molecules. And
  498. for that we started we initiated a
  499. innovation program green hydrogen, ?
  500. And at that time
  501. the hydrogen was not very much spoken
  502. about it, but there were already a few
  503. opportunities
  504. from EU funding. So we applied for EU
  505. funding for a large project for H2
  506. Future which got granted and it
  507. was actually a quite a
  508. a lighthouse project at the time.
  509. We deployed a 6 MW PEM proton exchange
  510. membrane electrolyzer
  511. at the steelworks in Linz at
  512. voestalpine. And at the time this was
  513. the world's largest electrolyzer to our
  514. knowledge. So world's largest PEM
  515. electrolyzer to our knowledge.
  516. >> How big was it? 6 6 MW at that time. So
  517. this was 2019 it went into operation. It
  518. was far
  519. before all the big projects and so were
  520. announced. So was a strong consortium,
  521. yeah, with voestalpine as the industrial
  522. partner.
  523. Siemens as technology provider. Then we
  524. had
  525. the Austrian TSO Austrian Power Grid as
  526. the grid operator. We had two research
  527. organizations in our consortium K1-Met
  528. and TNO from Holland. And voestalpine
  529. was coordinator and the utility. And
  530. actually I coordinated this project. It
  531. was very exciting, yeah.
  532. It was also really success story from EU
  533. side as well. We got prices and
  534. awards for that project because it was
  535. really a huge thing. And what we
  536. actually wanted to do is we wanted to
  537. deploy
  538. industrial electrolyzer in an industrial
  539. environment and
  540. see whether we could utilize it as a
  541. flexibility tool, yeah. See how we could
  542. actually use it for grid balancing and
  543. for some
  544. ancillary services like power to
  545. Like Yeah, yeah. Bit like power to X,
  546. yeah. Exactly. Project started in 2017
  547. and we went into operation late 2019,
  548. yeah, just before
  549. COVID, which was good because it ran
  550. then all automatically and we
  551. could run it
  552. and actually
  553. operate it from here as well, yeah.
  554. and we pre-qualified it for grid
  555. services for
  556. FCR, which is frequency containment
  557. reserve for
  558. AFRR, automated frequency restoration
  559. reserve on MFRR,
  560. manual frequency regulation reserve,
  561. which used to be primary, secondary, and
  562. tertiary reserve. We did that together
  563. with
  564. our partner Austrian Power Grid, the
  565. grid operator, and we qualified for all
  566. these services and now we're operating
  567. it mostly in the AFRR
  568. regime and we feed in the hydrogen
  569. the green hydrogen into the pipe system
  570. of voestalpine. So, it has been running
  571. since still in operation and was
  572. quite a milestone. We learned a
  573. a lot a very a lot about operating
  574. electrolyzers and
  575. what are the boundaries, how can you
  576. actually start how quickly can you
  577. start them up, shut them down, and
  578. all these kind of things. Have you been
  579. involved in any current projects as well
  580. for hydrogen? Not in any current
  581. projects but
  582. there's probably one one project that
  583. might be interesting to you as well
  584. because it concerns the CE region
  585. as well. So, in 2018 I had the idea
  586. for a project they called it green
  587. hydrogen at Blue Danube
  588. where the idea was to produce green
  589. hydrogen in Romania and Bulgaria out of
  590. renewables. We saw from our operations
  591. that there was enough space for wind and
  592. so and it was quite, quite easy to
  593. produce wind there, and then convert
  594. the renewable energy into green hydrogen
  595. and ship it along the river Danube to
  596. off-takers, let's say, in Austria or in
  597. southern Germany, Bavaria. So, this was
  598. the plan.. And we did a feasibility
  599. study for that, and it turned out that
  600. well, transportation and so, it was it
  601. was too expensive, yeah, Yeah. at the
  602. time, unfortunately, yeah. So, we
  603. didn't continue with this project, but I
  604. think it was a one of these early
  605. projects. It was quite visionary because
  606. it was looking at international value
  607. chains for hydrogen at the time when
  608. nobody was talking about that, yeah. So,
  609. was unfortunately didn't turn out, it
  610. didn't materialize, yeah. We then, as a
  611. follow-up, did some smaller projects
  612. along the river Danube, but that was
  613. really something, I think,
  614. where we put our mark on the hydrogen
  615. landscape, as well. Okay. So, this
  616. hydrogen transportation through the
  617. Danube was thought in green ammonia
  618. or in fuel cells or pipelines? What was
  619. the idea? Yeah, very, very good
  620. question, and of course, we thought
  621. about that a lot, yeah. We also worked
  622. together with the Danube Commission,
  623. which is located in Budapest, yeah, to
  624. find out what are the best ways of
  625. transporting hydrogen or its derivatives
  626. on the river Danube, and originally, we
  627. thought the
  628. probably most pragmatic way was with
  629. liquid organic hydrogen carriers, LOHC,
  630. where hydrogen is chemically
  631. bonded to
  632. a liquid, and then it is debonded
  633. again, yeah, by a thermal process.
  634. >> With a low temperature, high pressure.
  635. Yeah, well, it's yeah, you
  636. it's
  637. hydrogen is not transported as hydrogen,
  638. but as a liquid then. It's It's but it's
  639. not liquefied, it's actually chemically
  640. bonded to a liquid, which is harmless
  641. and that can be transported like any
  642. other
  643. any other cargo on the river Danube.
  644. So, this was the big advantage because
  645. if you think into pressurized hydrogen
  646. or into liquid hydrogen also, you might
  647. have problems with all the locks around
  648. the
  649. Danube. So, we thought ooh
  650. we don't want to get into that. Yeah.
  651. Let's let's see whether this way would
  652. work and from a I think from a
  653. permission point of view, it
  654. the Danube Commission was quite quite
  655. sure, that
  656. there had to be a few policy changes
  657. probably, but that would have been
  658. possible, yeah.
  659. >> Yeah. And how do you call this
  660. process? With
  661. >> it's liquid organic hydrogen
  662. carriers, LOHC
  663. they are called, here.
  664. >> Okay. And they were working with a
  665. company in Germany actually on that,
  666. yeah. Yeah, there are some some
  667. interesting concepts out. We also
  668. looked, of course, a little bit into
  669. ammonia later on and so
  670. it's tricky, yeah. Yeah, the efficiency
  671. of the system.
  672. >> Yeah. Yeah, yeah, we also thought about
  673. probably producing other, let's say,
  674. hydrogen derivatives like e-fuels or so
  675. and then ship them. Yeah. But it gets,
  676. unfortunately, with every step that you
  677. add to the process, it gets it doesn't
  678. get cheaper.
  679. But you think like the other costs
  680. are coming down and. That's a that's
  681. a good
  682. question because already at that time
  683. many many consultants predicted that the
  684. electrolyzer costs and the cost of
  685. hydrogen would would come down. I was
  686. always a little bit doubtful about that
  687. because I'm a chemical engineer and I
  688. know such a hydrogen plant
  689. yeah, big part is balance of plant. Only
  690. a small part is the electrolyzer and the
  691. stacks, yeah, which actually could come
  692. down in costs when you scale up
  693. manufacturing, but balance of plant is
  694. let's say, mature technology. They're at
  695. the very end of their learning curve, so
  696. it will not really come down. So, it
  697. didn't surprise me too much that the
  698. cost didn't that much come down. And
  699. also, unfortunately, I think the
  700. willingness to pay of customers also not
  701. really not really increased. So, there's
  702. there's still this gap. Yeah.
  703. Yeah. But now that you are speaking
  704. about innovation, let's go deep into it.
  705. energy, we know
  706. that the technology
  707. is advancing faster than policy maker,
  708. faster than anything.
  709. So,
  710. what do you think is the role of
  711. innovation in energy transition? I think
  712. innovation is a
  713. is a key driver for any transition.
  714. Yeah, not only for the energy
  715. transition. Yeah, we have seen this in
  716. in many industries. Yeah, you
  717. know the examples. I don't have to
  718. I don't have to tell you. Yeah. So,
  719. I think we need innovation to really
  720. build
  721. a
  722. renewables system that is reliable,
  723. yeah, that is
  724. competitive, and that is affordable.
  725. Yeah, and
  726. innovation will help us to do that. And
  727. this will really actually trigger the
  728. energy transition. Think about
  729. Well, the other day I saw a graph in
  730. what parts of the world wind and solar
  731. are the cheapest energy sources. And I
  732. think it covered 2/3 of the world
  733. already, yeah. So, this is amazing,
  734. yeah. And this is driven by innovation,
  735. yeah. And this is really something that
  736. gives us the spirit that we have we can
  737. achieve something if we want to, yeah.
  738. And I think this is a prime example
  739. where innovation really
  740. is
  741. leads to this trigger
  742. where
  743. innovative technologies become cost
  744. competitive, and then they just run
  745. from themselves, yeah. And it's
  746. Yeah. And is there some particular
  747. innovation that you think that it
  748. will be disruptive or you would bet more
  749. Especially because we're both experts at
  750. the ahead of the curve of
  751. looking at the innovation.
  752. >> Yeah, yeah. We're always ahead of the
  753. curve.
  754. No, I'm just joking. well, . Yeah,
  755. that's it,
  756. because
  757. disruptions
  758. are hard to predict because otherwise
  759. you don't know the disruption. Yeah,
  760. yeah, yeah, a lot about these shocks.
  761. But, what I've experienced
  762. especially now in the last, let's say, 1
  763. or 2 years is there's that many
  764. disruptions are not driven by
  765. technology. They come from
  766. policy and poli- political shocks also,
  767. yeah. That actually
  768. lead to disruptions. We see this,
  769. yeah. We see this with taxes that all of
  770. a sudden
  771. show up, yeah.
  772. And that the whole geopolitical
  773. system is under flow right now. So, I
  774. think this very much disrupts our
  775. system, yeah. Or slows it down or makes
  776. it faster at some places, yeah. Can you
  777. think of any any example that in last 5
  778. to 10 years that you it just came and it
  779. disrupted the whole whole system and
  780. got adopted very fast?
  781. >> Of course, there's some some
  782. technologies that
  783. get quickly adopted, yeah.
  784. just to think of EVs, of EV charging,
  785. and then
  786. how that is now progressing, yeah.
  787. And about 5 or 10 years ago, it was,
  788. well, too expensive. There was this
  789. chicken and egg problem, and so on. But
  790. now, there are wall boxes
  791. everywhere, there are charging stations
  792. everywhere, there are EV cars
  793. everywhere. When you go out and you see
  794. them. And it's really I think it's I
  795. mean, it's disrupting the combustion
  796. engine industry, as you see in Germany,
  797. yeah. And
  798. it seems that we are probably a little
  799. bit overtaken by the Chinese right now.
  800. I see that they are pushing into our
  801. markets with their EVs, with the
  802. cost-competitive EVs. So, I think this
  803. could really lead to a complete change
  804. in our mobility. Just on that note,
  805. where where do you think like especially
  806. in the whole energy system right now,
  807. we have to agree that China and US they
  808. they somehow lead in some part
  809. of manufacturing. Where you think it's
  810. Austria leading or Europe as a whole is
  811. leading? That's a good question. I think
  812. probably you read that Draghi report,
  813. yeah?
  814. He laid out he
  815. well, said that Europe is very good in
  816. basic research, but we are not
  817. bringing research into products and into
  818. industrialization. I think this is where
  819. we are lacking. We are very good at
  820. basic research. We still have a lot of
  821. of patents and so, yeah. But we are
  822. lacking of getting this on the road,
  823. let's call it. And this is I think where
  824. we probably also need a little bit of a
  825. shift in the funding system, yeah? From
  826. funding basic research probably to
  827. funding pilots, first of a kind projects
  828. and so, to close this gap between
  829. lab scale
  830. or or or small-scale and real
  831. industrialization. This value of death
  832. that many companies are facing if they
  833. want to deploy new technologies, yeah?
  834. They do not get enough funding, venture
  835. funding to actually get the products out
  836. in the market. At Verbund AG, do you
  837. foster some some innovation with doing
  838. pilots as well?
  839. How does it go? And also
  840. maybe together with academia, with
  841. universities that you
  842. about research partners or
  843. just tell us a bit about like how how
  844. did the innovation system works
  845. between
  846. within Fairphone X? Let's start with the
  847. second part of the question with the
  848. collaborations with universities and
  849. then and partners. We think this is very
  850. important. Yeah, plays a very important
  851. role and we also have a kind of a
  852. a legacy on working with universities
  853. and partners and we see
  854. there
  855. is a lot happening. Yeah, we do not have
  856. a lot of research facilities or I
  857. actually almost no research facilities
  858. also here on our
  859. on our sites or in-house. So, we need to
  860. work with partners and we actually
  861. one of the projects that we recently
  862. started was a Christian Doppler
  863. laboratory with the Technical University
  864. of Vienna.. on the topic of
  865. oxygen ion batteries.
  866. It's caught our eyes because these
  867. batteries, they are non-combustible,
  868. they are not toxic and they do not use
  869. any critical minerals. So, Wow.
  870. It looks like a very interesting storage
  871. technology.
  872. The
  873. Technical University of Vienna has
  874. developed it to small scale, let's say 1
  875. cm by 1 cm as you as you do it in the
  876. lab at the university and we said,
  877. "Well,
  878. let's scale this up.
  879. Let's do a prototype with that and let's
  880. test the prototype at Fairphone." And I
  881. asked them how how we could do that and
  882. they said, "Well,
  883. this will take some time. We need to do
  884. some more research on that and scale
  885. it up and
  886. they suggested to do a Christian Doppler
  887. laboratory. So, we applied for one and
  888. we got it funded and it started on
  889. Jan- in January last year. And now we're
  890. already at 5 5 by 5 cm of our cells and
  891. we are
  892. trying to use different manufacturing
  893. technologies that are scalable so the
  894. manufacturability is also given. We try
  895. new material combinations and it's
  896. it's very exciting and the plan here
  897. is also to have a spin-off from the
  898. technical university
  899. for this
  900. for this technology. So, I think that's
  901. a very nice example where we see
  902. something,
  903. think about it because it would very
  904. well suit our our projects for
  905. co-location with wind and solar to have
  906. these these storage units. Yeah, they
  907. are
  908. non-toxic.. Local production, local
  909. manufacturing.
  910. >> Exactly. We could interview them,
  911. actually. Yeah, sure. I'll give you the
  912. contact. Yeah. Yeah. I'm definitely
  913. happy to do that. And this is other
  914. thing that we are doing is bridging
  915. innovation and startups with industry.
  916. Actually, yesterday we came back from
  917. Gdansk from a hackathon in critical
  918. infrastructure and the concept of
  919. hackathon of inviting professionals and
  920. students a whole weekend, 24 hours,
  921. working in a
  922. in
  923. working through some challenges and then
  924. coming coming up with a solution.
  925. It was super idea and especially in
  926. in the whole energy sector right now
  927. where
  928. so, we'll be doing one in March.
  929. yeah, it could be also for you to scout
  930. for some innovation. Exciting. Yeah, I
  931. mean, what we do actually, and this
  932. probably comes a little bit to the
  933. second part of the question, is we have
  934. a 50Hertz accelerator program already
  935. running for 5 years.
  936. >> Yeah.
  937. Where we do use cases and pilots with
  938. startups. And this addresses your first
  939. part of the question. Do we pilot with
  940. startups? Yes, we do. Yeah, we do and
  941. we also have some storage where we
  942. actually then invest in those startups
  943. because we also have 50Hertz Ventures,
  944. our investment subsidiary,
  945. >> together. where we can actually then
  946. see if in what startups we want to
  947. whether they have any funding rounds,
  948. and so on. And this this really comes
  949. together very nicely. And what led to
  950. it?, you said it's already
  951. been working for 5 years, right? Ex-
  952. exactly, yeah., Verbund is a is
  953. a large company. It's a it's a kind of a
  954. big tanker that moves, yeah?
  955. And it moves, and it moves steadily and
  956. very reliably, yeah?
  957. But sometimes you need these small
  958. boats. The energy energy transition is
  959. is a fast-moving, dynamic thing,
  960. yeah? So, we need these small boats
  961. where we can actually,
  962. yeah, find new ways, investigate new
  963. ways in a quick quick and easy way. And
  964. we see startups as these kind of quick
  965. boats, if you if you want to like yeah,
  966. if you see the analogy that that I
  967. wanted wanted to make here. One thing is
  968. to work with startups to
  969. see how we can actually use the products
  970. in our business units, yeah? Of course,
  971. they help our
  972. our core business, our daily business.
  973. But it's also also, of course,
  974. interesting to see where is growth
  975. potential in this and these startups,
  976. and where do we actually want to invest
  977. and see them
  978. not only as a strategic, but also as a
  979. financial investment. I'm thinking. And
  980. in this innovation, it's always the
  981. we are in the energy transition to get
  982. 100% renewables. How How do you see this
  983. last 10% of
  984. to get the 100%? Because it requires
  985. more technology, more innovation. I
  986. think here we have to be a bit careful,
  987. yeah? Because
  988. Well, let's talk about 100% renewable
  989. electricity first, yeah? Oh, and
  990. electricity is what? There's a big
  991. difference between electricity and
  992. energy. well, in Austria,
  993. we have I think around 85% renewable
  994. electricity. Verbund, as I said, is very
  995. proud of 98% renewables in our
  996. portfolio. And the Austrian Association,
  997. Österreichs Energie,
  998. has calculated that we need around, I
  999. think, 27 terawatt hours to get to the
  1000. goal to have 100% renewable in
  1001. electricity by 2030.. But, 100%
  1002. renewables mean
  1003. on an annual basis, yeah? And not on an
  1004. Exactly.
  1005. >> hourly or second basis or so, yeah? So,
  1006. there will be times of surplus, and
  1007. there will be times of deficit in the
  1008. electricity system as well, yeah? And of
  1009. course, these times of deficit, they are
  1010. the
  1011. expensive one when it comes to the last
  1012. 5 or 10% because they probably require
  1013. seasonal storage, I think, and then it
  1014. becomes really expensive, yeah?
  1015. So, the question that
  1016. I would ask is, how much is enough,
  1017. yeah?
  1018. If we would, let's say, go to 95%
  1019. renewable electricity, and the last 5%,
  1020. yeah? Couldn't we use the money that we
  1021. need to close this gap to 100%? Couldn't
  1022. we use this money also to
  1023. have a larger lever on the CO2 reduction
  1024. in another field, let's say, in heating
  1025. or in renovating houses or anything,
  1026. yeah? So, I think we already
  1027. very far, but 100%, I think it's it's
  1028. the expensive bit, and
  1029. where do do do we really want it? And if
  1030. we want to
  1031. go to a, let's say, a carbon neutral
  1032. system or so, there are many other
  1033. places where we if we would find them,
  1034. probably the money spent would go a go a
  1035. bit further than there. Let's call it
  1036. that. If you if what I what I
  1037. mean. I think
  1038. on paper, 100% renewables is
  1039. very good goal, and I think in practice,
  1040. it's very difficult to achieve, as you
  1041. said, the last last few percents are
  1042. very expensive.
  1043. >> And Rudy, going back to Fairbourne
  1044. Ventures, Yeah. please walk us
  1045. through
  1046. how they're operating, what is the
  1047. current portfolio,
  1048. what are the stages that Fairbund
  1049. accelerator works in, the ticket size,
  1050. and also geography.
  1051. is it like Austria-centric or it does
  1052. not have any
  1053. geography focus? Yeah. So, there are two
  1054. things. There's the Fairbund accelerator
  1055. that we started around 5 years ago,
  1056. which is, it's an accelerator
  1057. program for pilots. But about 2 years
  1058. ago, we started with Fairbund Ventures,
  1059. which is actually the investment vehicle
  1060. of Fairbund to invest in startups, yeah.
  1061. And we have a investment thesis there.
  1062. We invest in late seed and series A up
  1063. to 2 and 1/2 million euros, and our
  1064. local focus is Europe. So, our portfolio
  1065. spans all over Europe, and we invest in
  1066. the clean tech sector, clean energy
  1067. sector.. Yeah. So, this is basically
  1068. the concept, and then these are the
  1069. boundaries in that we
  1070. we act in Fairbund Ventures. And what
  1071. are the stages? Do you have any specific
  1072. like seed, A, B, or the later stages?
  1073. It's late seed and series A. These are
  1074. the stages where we invest. And in this
  1075. journey, what has been the biggest
  1076. surprise of sources of
  1077. innovation, like spin-off, universities,
  1078. or series founders, or Well,
  1079. there are there are many sources, yeah.
  1080. There's the accelerator that I mentioned
  1081. my my colleagues they attend a lot of
  1082. events and they have a very good
  1083. network, and I think the network is
  1084. extremely important in the venture
  1085. scene. There is a lot of
  1086. word of mouth, people talking
  1087. about things and one
  1088. investor telling you his or or their
  1089. deal flow, yeah. And you just have a
  1090. lot of exchanges with others and then
  1091. see what what they think where where
  1092. things are going with various
  1093. companies and so. So, I think
  1094. this network is extremely important
  1095. and also it surprised me here that it's
  1096. really such a strong. driver for
  1097. finding the best best investments there.
  1098. >> it helps to find this needle in the
  1099. middle of the straw. I don't know if you
  1100. have this.
  1101. >> In the middle of the haystack, yeah,
  1102. yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, exactly, yeah.
  1103. Because well, we screen
  1104. couple of hundred
  1105. startups each year and we have invested
  1106. so far in about 10, yeah. So, it's
  1107. really finding this needle in a haystack
  1108. as you as you said, yeah. And that's
  1109. time consuming, but you get better and
  1110. better. You see what you have to watch
  1111. out for., what is the average ticket
  1112. size for the investment at Fairpoint
  1113. Deutsch?
  1114. >> Around 1 and 1/2 to 2 million, I would
  1115. say. So, maximum is 2 and 1/2 million,
  1116. yeah. Okay. And how do you measure
  1117. success
  1118. in this investment and scouting? Well,
  1119. we are we are quite new in the game.
  1120. 2 years ago. Of course, we have defined
  1121. KPIs on how the
  1122. how the startups are performing. They
  1123. have some KPIs, revenue and
  1124. and
  1125. growth areas and
  1126. sales cycles, how long they take and
  1127. then all these kind of, let's say,
  1128. parameters
  1129. vary from from startup to startup, yeah.
  1130. And we have
  1131. we are very engaged with our startups as
  1132. well. So, we are
  1133. >> Okay.
  1134. usually on
  1135. on the board
  1136. either as a board member or
  1137. advisory member or or observing member.
  1138. And
  1139. we also try to link them with our
  1140. business units because
  1141. we do strategic investments that relate
  1142. to our business units as well. And one
  1143. of the successes is of course if there
  1144. comes some deal out of that, yeah, that
  1145. the business units works with the
  1146. startup. So, this is this is something,
  1147. yeah.
  1148. There's a nice example of a Romanian
  1149. startup.
  1150. Back to the to see
  1151. I said we invest in the
  1152. all over Europe.
  1153. There's a company Romanian company Ogar
  1154. AI they are called and they do
  1155. forecasting for EV charging points. And
  1156. they were part of our accelerator. They
  1157. did a pilot with one of our business
  1158. units of smart weeks and we saw that
  1159. they had potential and so we invested in
  1160. them. So we are now invested in Ogar
  1161. AI and our business units are working
  1162. with them. And the accelerator program
  1163. is
  1164. how long is the program? We do batches,
  1165. yeah. Yeah. It has been running for 5
  1166. years. I think we've done nine batches
  1167. or so. Probably
  1168. eight nine batches. So we would do one
  1169. or two batches each each year. It's
  1170. actually a
  1171. a collaboration program where we have
  1172. other
  1173. industrial partners as well. Yeah,
  1174. there's a long list of partners actually
  1175. that are either real partners or
  1176. associated partners for that and we
  1177. define use cases. I think we've done
  1178. around
  1179. 50 use cases, roughly 50 use cases.
  1180. With those startups.
  1181. We have done a selection phase, yeah,
  1182. and then a pitch phase which is usually
  1183. online and then there's a
  1184. kind of a demonstration day we invite
  1185. the winners. How long is the batch
  1186. over the year? It runs for
  1187. well, the whole process is probably
  1188. around the half a year. Yeah.
  1189. From from the very first scouting we
  1190. usually work with some partners on
  1191. the scouting as well until we
  1192. we have to demo day where the
  1193. the startups then also invited.
  1194. >> And currently
  1195. is there any scope that you're
  1196. particularly looking into the startups
  1197. or any particular area? We have defined
  1198. some, we call them, investment
  1199. thesis for areas where we look into
  1200. and they are
  1201. partly
  1202. quite broad, yeah. It's sustainable
  1203. energy production, it's green mobility,
  1204. and it's,
  1205. flow and flexibility, we call them. So,
  1206. these are the main areas and there
  1207. are now some areas around that coming as
  1208. well with some
  1209. newer technologies, some deep tech that
  1210. we are
  1211. looking into. So, we started with our
  1212. core
  1213. expertise and we are now like trying to
  1214. look a little bit outside that as well
  1215. because we see that many of the really
  1216. interesting things happen at the
  1217. interfaces between disciplines and
  1218. between technologies and so on and so.
  1219. This is why we're moving in that
  1220. direction as well.
  1221. >> So, now look looking to the future.
  1222. what do you think about this,
  1223. disruptive technologies as, carbon
  1224. capture, we are facing now
  1225. digitalization in the grid,
  1226. we scoped this, project with AIT
  1227. about, high temperature heat pumps
  1228. because we also share that, energy
  1229. consumption is 22 to 23% electrical, the
  1230. rest is, a bit of biomass and the
  1231. rest is fuel. How do you see the energy
  1232. sector
  1233. this technologies,
  1234. carbon capture, digitalization,
  1235. heat pumps,
  1236. geothermal now also coming.,
  1237. there are so many external drivers to
  1238. that, yeah, like policies and politics
  1239. and, how the demand will actually
  1240. increase or decrease, in what
  1241. fields, in what regions and so. And
  1242. these are all drivers that will actually
  1243. lead to one or the other technology to
  1244. probably to be dominant in one part of
  1245. the world, yeah. Will it then just also
  1246. come to other parts of the
  1247. This is so difficult to say, yeah? I
  1248. mean, we see, of course, that
  1249. electrification is quite strongly
  1250. pushed.
  1251. I have to say that because I'm working
  1252. for an electricity company, so
  1253. electricity electricity first, yeah.
  1254. And as we talked about renewables and
  1255. renewable penetration earlier on, so
  1256. electricity becomes very very green,
  1257. very low CO2 footprint. I think what you
  1258. can actually electrify
  1259. electrify.
  1260. Because
  1261. these are the lower hanging fruits
  1262. still. So, we see electrification of
  1263. heating by heat pumps, probably also by
  1264. lower temperature industrial heat
  1265. applications, yeah? We see
  1266. electrification in the mobility sector,
  1267. of course, with
  1268. EVs, and we see that more and more
  1269. trucks are now probably going this
  1270. direction with mega chargers. So, I
  1271. think this is unstoppable. What you can
  1272. electrify, you will electrify, yeah? And
  1273. then there are probably some of the
  1274. hard-to-abate sectors. We had steel
  1275. earlier on, fertilizer is probably
  1276. another one, yeah? Cement, yeah? Yeah.
  1277. And there I think we
  1278. we need a probably a holistic European
  1279. view on that as well. What industries do
  1280. we actually
  1281. want in what value chain steps here in
  1282. Europe, yeah? Do we Well, nowadays,
  1283. let's say we import iron ore from
  1284. Brazil, from
  1285. Australia, or so, yeah?
  1286. Would it be thinkable to
  1287. import in the future not iron ore, but
  1288. hot briquetted iron, yeah? Use
  1289. renewables in Australia, a lot of sun,
  1290. cheap renewables,
  1291. produce green hydrogen, and produce hot
  1292. briquetted iron there, and ship that as
  1293. a pre-product to Europe. Then you have
  1294. still a lot of the value chain here
  1295. covered in Europe with the
  1296. processing, the steel making, all the
  1297. quality products making out of it. But
  1298. you have
  1299. shifted the energy demand from Europe to
  1300. another part of the world where you
  1301. probably
  1302. are not so restricted by
  1303. place and by resources. This is
  1304. something I'm a little bit missing.
  1305. Probably you can start in the CEE
  1306. region, yeah? Think about that whether
  1307. each individual country needs their
  1308. steel work, needs their fertilizer
  1309. plant, needs their cement plant, or
  1310. could there be a kind of a unified
  1311. European strategy on that, yeah?
  1312. Interesting. And just in that note of
  1313. electrification, we recently went to
  1314. China
  1315. and we visited some
  1316. like associations and
  1317. some institute of research and they told
  1318. us that they're nearly 40% electrified.
  1319. And they're keeping pushing. Yeah. So,
  1320. it's
  1321. maybe it's a big opportunity to
  1322. Europe also to electrify more, find the
  1323. gaps, and push more electricity in a
  1324. with clean resources. So, it's Exactly.
  1325. Yeah, I think that's the way forward,
  1326. yeah. And that's probably the transition
  1327. the energy transition is all about,
  1328. yeah? This is way to renewables and
  1329. penetrate as many
  1330. sectors as possible. Rudolf, I would add
  1331. that we think of energy transition to
  1332. be a technological challenge. It's
  1333. also a skill challenge. we were I was
  1334. just looking into the IEA energy
  1335. employment outlook. Do you think there's
  1336. professional shortage in the industry
  1337. right now or
  1338. going forward, what are the going what
  1339. are going to be the critical skills
  1340. and that the Europe needs to have its
  1341. own workforce going forward also to
  1342. drive this transition forward? So, what
  1343. what what do you think it's missing and
  1344. what you think about if there's really a
  1345. shortage or where is the industry right
  1346. now? Build out of renewables is far
  1347. faster than the talent that's created to
  1348. actually do that. Yeah, so there's
  1349. definitely a gap in
  1350. electrical engineers and in
  1351. software engineers and so and also
  1352. in maintenance people or who actually
  1353. do the on-ground work there as well. And
  1354. at Verbund we have a special approach
  1355. there because we also have a an
  1356. apprenticeship program here where we
  1357. have a
  1358. a program for young people to do
  1359. apprenticeships in mechanical and
  1360. electrical engineering combined. Yeah.
  1361. at three of our sites we have
  1362. three places where we actually do this
  1363. this education for them. And we These
  1364. are actually the
  1365. the future plant operators for us and
  1366. they know our plants then very well. We
  1367. need these people who are actually
  1368. very familiar with hydropower, with
  1369. everything that we do here.. And
  1370. they also more more looking into
  1371. into photovoltaics and into wind of
  1372. course. Yeah, we have a team of wind
  1373. experts that do all the maintenance. We
  1374. have actually brought this in-house
  1375. already about 10 years ago. This was one
  1376. of my jobs when I was in charge of wind
  1377. and solar operations. to cut costs we
  1378. created a team that is on-site at our
  1379. wind farms in Upper and the latter
  1380. and Lower Austria that actually does
  1381. maintenance. So this was also quite a
  1382. quite a new concept at that time. so
  1383. we get a lot of skill in-house and that
  1384. helps us to build on this on this
  1385. skilled skilled people I think. Yeah.
  1386. So you see the problem but you are
  1387. solving it inside.
  1388. >> We're trying to mitigate it. Yeah, we're
  1389. trying to mitigate the problem
  1390. by having the workforce also in-house
  1391. that we are more flexible here. We were
  1392. supposed to move to the clothing and
  1393. your personal insights. I just have
  1394. one question because
  1395. yesterday I thought that there had been
  1396. a trade deal between free trade
  1397. agreement between EU and India.
  1398. What do you think it entails for
  1399. just on the skilled talent? I thought
  1400. that it's going to be
  1401. I see more
  1402. skills and more professionals going to
  1403. India to help their their journey. But
  1404. do you have any opinion? Like what do
  1405. you think of this FTA? I have seen it in
  1406. the news, but I haven't followed it up
  1407. very closely to be honest, yeah.
  1408. But I'm
  1409. think about all the software engineers
  1410. in India. There are such a lot of
  1411. skill there, yeah, that we want to tap
  1412. into here in Europe as well, of course.
  1413. And
  1414. I think
  1415. Europe will
  1416. will make it probably will very much
  1417. profit from that from that agreement,
  1418. yeah. And
  1419. I said earlier on I did my my PhD in UK,
  1420. yeah. So there are many Indian people
  1421. there. There's a huge community and
  1422. they are
  1423. super super integrated in everything
  1424. and I think this should happen in
  1425. continental Europe as well, yeah. So
  1426. also to bring people here. We see that
  1427. in India there is such a huge growth in
  1428. renewables in solar and so it's
  1429. just amazing, yeah. 30 gigawatt project
  1430. >> Yeah, I was recently talking with some
  1431. of the state utilities and
  1432. what they want to learn from here is a
  1433. lot of the grid infrastructure because
  1434. they also need to modernize and
  1435. and there's a lot of software component
  1436. that Europe has already advanced. And
  1437. also the power market has not been
  1438. liberalized in India. It hasn't opened
  1439. yet. Okay.
  1440. >> And that is something that there's a lot
  1441. of learning for them. So I feel that the
  1442. professional outflow is going to be a
  1443. lot, especially in the energy sector,
  1444. from Europe to India.
  1445. >> It will be in both directions. I'm sure
  1446. it will be in both directions, yeah.
  1447. Green infrastructure is an interesting
  1448. one, yeah., there are also new
  1449. technologies out there, innovations like
  1450. HVDC and so on. India is a huge huge
  1451. subcontinent, a huge country. You might
  1452. actually tap into some of the
  1453. innovations here
  1454. and make use of it, yeah. Definitely. We
  1455. can make the bridge in some point,
  1456. right?
  1457. >> Yeah.
  1458. There has to be one.
  1459. Yeah. So, now in the
  1460. just to be closing and wrapping up,
  1461. in a personal level,
  1462. what would you like to be your your
  1463. legacy in energy transition? This
  1464. looking this young teenager making a
  1465. hydropower plant in a remote area, now
  1466. in the biggest utility fostering
  1467. innovation.
  1468. How do you see it? Well, there were a
  1469. few other projects in between., yeah,
  1470. sure sure sure.
  1471. No, no. Yeah, yeah,
  1472. well, this is something for a different
  1473. for a different different time, yeah. I
  1474. said,
  1475. my fulfillment is to work for Verbund,
  1476. which is a green and renewable
  1477. company, and we
  1478. at the time I've been with Verbund, we
  1479. have extended our footprint all over
  1480. Europe. So, I think this expansion is
  1481. very important, yeah. This is also a
  1482. a legacy that drives me, that we do not
  1483. only concentrate on Austria, but I
  1484. think we have to
  1485. to bring renewables and build the energy
  1486. system of the
  1487. of the future to all over Europe. I
  1488. think this is this is one of the
  1489. legacies, and Verbund wants to invest
  1490. around 6 billion euros. We had a 1
  1491. billion question earlier. We're
  1492. investing 6 billions between 25 and 29
  1493. and 27 in green infrastructure, in
  1494. renewables, in storage, in
  1495. innovative technologies. So, there's a
  1496. lot of money going into that, and this
  1497. is in times when there is an industrial
  1498. downturn in Europe. So, we are really
  1499. putting
  1500. our money where our mouth is. We really
  1501. invest, and I think this is something
  1502. that has to be said sometimes as
  1503. well, yeah, because I think it's very
  1504. important for the for the economy
  1505. here, and this is, I think, how we can
  1506. actually
  1507. make a big difference for decarbonizing
  1508. and building up building back Europe.
  1509. And just in the personal level that
  1510. we were talking about this before
  1511. recording, but in a personal level,
  1512. you live sustainability by yourself.
  1513. Just to ask you, how do you live in
  1514. your daily life? You have to be aware of
  1515. it, yeah. You have to be aware of
  1516. sustainability, and it's sometimes not
  1517. so easy. Yeah, the other day I read a
  1518. book.
  1519. It's called How Bad Are Bananas? Okay.
  1520. Mike Berners-Lee.
  1521. and
  1522. before you ask, they're not as bad as
  1523. Avocados are far worse, yeah. Oh, wow.
  1524. Because of their transport, yeah, to
  1525. Europe. And this is actually quite an
  1526. eye-opener, because it talks about
  1527. different
  1528. products, different actions or so, and
  1529. what actual footprint is
  1530. involved in those. And then you see,
  1531. makes you think about your your actions,
  1532. yeah. Your your own consumption. Your
  1533. own consumptions, yeah.
  1534. And of course, there are some some
  1535. no-brainers. I used to have a gas
  1536. boiler. I have a heat pump now. I have
  1537. solar PV on my roof.
  1538. That's for sure, yeah. And this is how I
  1539. try to make life as sustainable as
  1540. possible. About banana, just a fun
  1541. fact, one of the first
  1542. war
  1543. or fight between European powers
  1544. in I think in 17th or 18th century was
  1545. also about banana valley chain. Okay,
  1546. wow. Yeah.
  1547. but
  1548. what would you say like some of your
  1549. advice
  1550. for the for the
  1551. next generation which is coming into the
  1552. industry? What advice you will give for
  1553. for them to acquire the skills or just
  1554. in general
  1555. where the industry is going?
  1556. Yeah, so now we're listening carefully
  1557. to an advice from an old man.
  1558. No, I just just just joking. What what I
  1559. found in my life is that
  1560. try to be interdisciplinary, yeah?
  1561. Because I think especially if you are
  1562. curious and you have to be curious, I
  1563. think, there you find the niches and the
  1564. really interesting stuff, yeah? So
  1565. I think try always to be open open to
  1566. new things and try to look a bit
  1567. outside
  1568. outside the box, little bit beyond what
  1569. you normally do, yeah? I think that's
  1570. that's very important.
  1571. I think it's also important to learn
  1572. about fundamentals, yeah? About
  1573. processes, about products, about
  1574. customers, and so forth. Really learn
  1575. learn the nitty-gritty as well, yeah? Do
  1576. not stay on the surface, but dig deep
  1577. from time to time. I think that's also
  1578. very important and that's probably a
  1579. skill
  1580. that has to be
  1581. also learned in school a bit more, yeah?
  1582. Really go go a bit deeper, yeah? And I
  1583. think it's also a good idea to build a
  1584. strong network. Strong professional
  1585. network, yeah? Strong network also from
  1586. university as you as you do. You're
  1587. from the master's
  1588. program of the
  1589. of the Technical University. By the
  1590. way, I used to be a lecturer there.
  1591. oh wow.
  1592. I guess for if yeah, I made some finance
  1593. seminars in Prague and so. Yeah, and
  1594. similar advice for people who want
  1595. corporate investment from Ferb und so
  1596. weiter. Like budding startup. Well,
  1597. yeah, they have to do a bit more.
  1598. Yeah, but it's a super good advice
  1599. because now, especially with AI,
  1600. many sectors can be merged and create
  1601. new careers, new perspectives. It's a
  1602. new world ahead. There's such a lot of
  1603. knowledge out there and it's just on the
  1604. on the tip of your fingers. Yeah. If
  1605. you're in front of a of a laptop.
  1606. Literally.
  1607. And now the new section to finalize with
  1608. quick fire round. So, in your
  1609. experience, what is could be the most
  1610. overhyped technology? Escaping the
  1611. climate crisis by inhabiting other
  1612. planets like Mars because
  1613. Wow.
  1614. It's so desperate.
  1615. >> Yeah. Yeah. I think that's the Like Elon
  1616. Musk said in the in Davos that he
  1617. wanted to create Star Trek Yeah.
  1618. >> kind of this way. Well, yeah. Probably
  1619. probably I am too old for this stuff.
  1620. I don't know. So,
  1621. what would you say is the most
  1622. underrated enabler in any transition?
  1623. >> Yeah, I think what we also found out as
  1624. a regulated utility, it's customers
  1625. because they only buy what they want,
  1626. yeah? And you have to give them what
  1627. they want. So, really there has to be
  1628. focus on customers, I think, for
  1629. everybody. You were already talking
  1630. about a
  1631. the book. Any other book that you would
  1632. recommend?
  1633. Well, Especially for people who want
  1634. some investment.
  1635. Yeah, then you will have to learn the
  1636. basics of
  1637. >> And I thought
  1638. over there the book went your mindset.
  1639. Yeah, that's that's one that you can
  1640. read, of course, yeah.
  1641. It's on my bedside table.
  1642. No, well, one one book that's probably
  1643. quite interesting is called
  1644. Sustainable Energy Without the Hot Air.
  1645. It's by
  1646. by David MacKay from
  1647. Cambridge University. And it's it's
  1648. quite an eye-opener and I read it
  1649. cover to cover. So, it's it's really
  1650. good. It's very readable, very very
  1651. well written and you can download it
  1652. actually for free. Yeah. You can
  1653. either buy it as a
  1654. hard copy, but you can also download it
  1655. for free. So, that's really Okay, we are
  1656. going to add it in the description of
  1657. the video. Perfect. Yeah. How would you
  1658. describe the energy grid in the Austrian
  1659. energy grid in 10 years? The Austrian
  1660. energy grid in 10 years will be very
  1661. resilient.
  1662. >> On that note, thank you very much Rudolf
  1663. for giving us time. It had been a very
  1664. insightful session. Yeah, thank And also
  1665. very funny.
  1666. Thank you for having me.
  1667. Yeah, thank you Rudolf and also for the
  1668. community for watching the video and the
  1669. interview until the end and stay tuned
  1670. for future interviews. Ciao. Thank you.